The following was released to clients and select prospective clients in January. I hope you find it interesting!
Camarda Financial’s Special Reports:
2007 Annual Investors’ Markets Forecast
Clients and limited select distribution only
Do not post to public assess area of Camarda.com
The beginning of the year is a wonderful time, for many things. To reflect on blessings past, present, and for the future, and to try to chart a better course to bring the future blessings for which we hope to be thankful for in years to come.
Since money is such a powerful tool to help make the time for the things we love, and to enhance the quality of the life we wish to have, it is a good time to reflect on the decisions we have made, the places we might want to be, and the strategic changes we might want to make to maximize the opportunities likely to come to pass in the days and months to come.
It is a popular time for planning, and for predictions. Here are mine on the capital factors and markets, with the usual caveats that things are NOT likely to unfold as I have foreseen. Some probably won’t happen, some may, and some may (or not) for reasons different than I may think. While useful and interesting, these should not be relied on as absolute “bet the ranch” divinations of what will transpire. Rather, you may choose to deeply consider them, along with other sources, before perhaps allowing them to slightly color the well-considered risk control systems you currently use (or should be using) to manage your investment lives. Hopefully, my research and opinions can help you (and us) squeeze a bit more juice out of your (and our) prudent judgment and investment management decisions.
For those of you that have seem my forecasts before, please do not be swayed by what you may consider to be my uncanny accuracy in the past. Every day, it’s a brand new world, and the only constant is that unpredictable change can and will befall us.
That said, here’s what I think.
2006 Summary
Let’s begin with a quick review of 2006’s major events. The US housing market – one of the very central elements driving the American economy – undeniably collapsed into the vacuum of a bubble created by one of the hottest and most protracted real estate markets of a generation. The Fed, under a new chairman, finally relented from years of steadily increasing interest rates, though, apparently, too late to pump up the housing bubble, at least for 2006. The war in Iraq, and the other in Afghanistan, became increasingly unproductive, unpopular, and un-winnable, at least in the sense for which they were originally prosecuted. Meanwhile, east across the axis of evil, Iran supported Hezbollah into the first seemingly successful war against Israel ever, while even farther out Kim Jong Il, bane of both President Bush and the North Korean people, had the audacity to both launch (unsuccessfully, thank the maker) a missile with the design-range to reach US territory, and detonate what appears to be a weapons-grade nuclear device. Oil surged, for a time, and the dollar dove. The stock markets plunged through midsummer, and the experts raved that the inverted yield curve presaged recession. The Democrats took control of both houses, and the administration’s stand and staff on war matters quickly softened.
It was a murky, challenging, wrenching year.
But US companies coined money, and the markets soared like they haven’t in three years. On the wind of fear and misfortune, the bull thrust higher through 2006.
What about next year?
The US housing market will continue to suffer. Foreclosures will increase, roiling the derivatives bond markets, and lenders, predictably, will tighten credit standards (even for those for whom they should not) only now that the horse has fled the barn. Prices will drop, as those wishing to sell make peace with the fact that 2005 is gone and things have changed. Accelerating price drops, sellers’ anxiety, and lenders’ woes: buyers will be scarce, frightened, and renting while they “wait and see.” While northeast Florida, Camarda’s home market, spared much of the bubble’s froth and still a relative bargain, will be far more stable than elsewhere, the pain has already begun and will become more acute before things begin to turn in 2008/09. Buys in single-family housing will emerge for rentals investors later in the year; prices and seller expectations, while beginning to slip, are still too high now. Rents will continue to rise.
The US commercial real estate market will plateau and begin to decline. While not nearly so severe as residential, commercial’s been on quite a tear lately, and this trend continues despite flagging rates of return (“cap rates”); investors seem willing to take on more risk in exchange for lower returns, never a good sign. Unlike for single-family and other “small” residential, long-term leases with high credit-quality tenants in commercial buildings, and apartment rents rising with the demand for housing for those who can no longer afford to buy, can mitigate this to some degree, but risk looms, especially for those investing in investment pools like REIT’s where share prices may increasingly be disconnected from the economic reality on the ground (sorry, couldn’t resist), at least for a time. Shares in REIT’s are at risk of a severe price tumble. Commercial “cap rates” – essentially expected return – are way down, meaning buyers are willing to take more risk for less return, never a good sign.
US interest rates will normalize. Short-term rates (the ones the Fed controls and you hear about all the time) will stay level, then decline as inflation abates and the economy slows in mid-cycle. Long term rates will increase and eventually overtake declining short rates, erasing the current “inverted” yield curve (where short rates are higher than long) that has caused so much nail biting and predictions of recession, and bringing forth a “flat” curve (where shorter and longer rates are about the same) or a more “normal” curve where rates get higher the longer the term. Please note that I am in the definite minority on this prediction – many predict a flat or still-inverted curve by year-end – and that interest rate predictions are about as complex and unreliable as currency forecasts. But if I am right prices for longer-term bonds will fall. The quality spread – price differences between better and poorer rated bonds – will widen to more normal levels, and prices for bonds of lower quality will fall.
The US economy will chug along. The Fed – after 17 successive interest rate hikes – will have engineered a “soft landing,” and economic growth will continue at a more moderate pace. Inflation will hover near the Fed’s 2% target. Workers’ real incomes will continue their recent increase, reversing an unhappy near-decade trend, and this will fuel consumption and growth. Unemployment will remain “safely” above labor-shortage levels, and lost jobs from a higher minimum wage will “help” this. US companies’ torrid profit margins will slow, then rise again as massive cash hoards are deployed in search of corporate growth. “Goldilocks” (an economy of not-too-fast, not-too-slow growth) will smile. Despite protracted trade deficits (which probably no longer accurately measure “balance of ‘trade’” issues, anyway) I believe the US economy to be in remarkably healthy, mature shape. On big benefit of globalization, yet to be widely appreciated is that outsourcing labor and manufacture to emerging markets like China spawns benefits far beyond lower prices for consumer goods; Far beyond cost savings, American companies have learned to transfer the dangerous, cyclical risk of manufacture (demand up, build factories, prices rise, demand down, shutter factories, layoff workers, recession) to foreign companies and workers, whilst still capturing most of the profit! This has already led, I think, to safer, gentler economic cycles and better, more stable jobs for workers, and the trend will accelerate in my view. This has resulted in far more favorable rates of relative wealth increase– the US is getting richer faster than the countries it is outsourcing its manufacture to – and this may be a better way to measure trade in the modern age. For this and other reasons, US stocks will continue to soar through 2007 and beyond as American and others see great value in our companies and great stability in the dollar.
The world will become more dangerous as the fundamentalist-terrorist ethos becomes endemic across the globe. Iraq will transform into the premier incubator of exported misery, and Afghanistan will regain much of its former stature in this regard. This problem will spread into formally stable regions like Thailand. New threats will arise in Africa and South America. Absent a significant nuclear event, this will not materially affect average global economic activity or investment opportunity. China’s rise as a new superpower will become evident; it’s influence and responsibility will wax, even as internal problems increase.
Democrats in control of both Congressional houses will increasingly call the tune as a war-beleaguered President approaches the lame duck zone. The minimum wage will leap from $5.15 to $7.25, a whopper of a 41% jump that is sure to cost workers hours and jobs, and add to inflation where the jobs can’t be scaled back, automated, or otherwise eliminated. All hope for estate tax repeal will die, and tax rates on the “rich” will begin to creep up again here as the Democrats pursue expensive social policy, and the massive Social Security deficit crisis looms ever near. Death tax rates will eventually revisit their old pre-reform peaks, as will income taxes, as higher brackets and the AMT squeeze even more from high earners and even those of modest means. IRS audits of high-income filers will rise dramatically as Treasury scrambles to capture more revenue by dredging high-cash-flow targets with fine-tooth combs. This trend was clear in 2006 and will gain unpleasant traction as 2007 unfolds. Odds of audit have gone up substantially, and those selected will face longer and more invasive examinations. Top income tax rates will again approach the Clinton-era’s 40% – before the additional Social Security/FICA taxes are considered. And the caps on income subject to the Social Security tax – an additional 12.4% split between taxpayers and their employers – will be raised sky-high or removed entirely, extracting from Americans to another $100 billion in taxes for each year alone; sadly, this money will be promptly “borrowed” and spent by the government, rather than used to put a dent in the Social Security welfare system that, due to longevity gains unforeseeable when the New Deal was dealt, has grown massively more expensive and generous than anything ever intended even by FDR.
The dollar will stabilize, then go up. So many factors – the trade accounts with various countries, the efforts of the US and foreign central banks (like China’s, but they all do it) to manage their economic aims via currency trading, the influence of US exporters (who want a weak dollar), US interest rates, US voters (who want good jobs from a weak dollar but cheap imported goods from a strong dollar) and unexpected market forces (like the fact that the dollar has become the de facto world currency, driving demand for greenbacks unrelated to goods/services) make currency predictions and bets fraught with risk. Still, I’ll stick my neck out a bit and call for a rising dollar against European currencies, and a falling dollar against Asian currencies, especially those other than the yen. Overall, the dollar will stabilize, and move gradually up. If this happens, non-dollar investments in foreign assets like stocks and bonds will be negatively affected in dollar terms. China and India – clearly new economic superpowers of the new century – will see growth abate as economies mature; the Chinese will allow their currency to rise against the dollar, raising prices for many US consumer goods from the Far East.
Commodities prices – especially oil – will decline moderately, as global demand slows from greater efficiencies, sharply curtailed US construction, and especially as overall emerging markets’ (overwhelmingly led by China) appetites contract due to slowing rates of economic growth; many emerging markets will, however, consume more basic goods. This trend will be exacerbated by diminished speculative fervor, and discovery of both new sources of alternative and in-the-ground resources, and new technologies to exploit these resources. Many countervailing forces will conspire to produce slightly lower prices for commodities.
US Large Cap stocks will continue to rise, based on strong fundamentals and the “rotation” of investor interest. The Dow will continue to make new highs, and finish 2007 near 14,000. The S&P 500 will finally break it’s 2000 record and rise to new highs – in the 1600 range – and even the mega-cap-moribund NASDAQ will regain much lost ground and approach it’s 2000 high, but still finish well shy of it.
US Small Caps will pause from their record run ups, and see slower share-price growth or even end flat to slightly down, finally yielding to investor rotation and showing lower PE’s. This will prove temporary, as these growth engines on the cutting edge benefit from a benign US economic environment and easing interest rates. Nonetheless, small caps are due for a breather, and large caps will clearly lead the US markets in my view.
Foreign “first world” stocks will show moderating growth, as rotation continues toward US large caps, and the dollar rebounds, cutting returns on international investments from the American perspective. This is despite the fact that valuations of many EAFE (Europe, Africa, Far East – a good foreign index) in many ways can be viewed as less dear – and hence better buys – than US stocks, and so more worthy of investor attention. The “rotation” factor will reduce US investor demand, as will the higher (probably unjustified) perceived risk of these stocks, and a rising dollar will sodden things more. Overall, I look for positive but only single-digit growth here.
Select Emerging Markets will continue to soar, offering heady returns with dizzying risk. Emerging markets – what we used to call “third world” generally refer to rapidly developing economies, from “adolescent” to “young mature,” like post Soviet-bloc East Europe, Southeast Asia, Korea, and China, all of South and Central America, and so on. This is in contrast to “foreign” which tends to mean developed non-US economies like Britain, Canada, Germany, and Japan. Without question, the future of world growth belongs to these emerging economies as they hurtle, with information-age/globalized-trade speed, to the levels of development enjoyed by countries such as ours. Fortunes to rival America’s gilded age will be made in places like these, and by those investors prescient enough to spot the winners among companies and countries. The emerging world is yet filled with lessening but still staggering risk, and these waters are not to be transversed lightly. If you sail, do your homework, spread your risk, and keep the cannons loaded for pirates.
Forecast Summery: Avoid real estate & REIT’s, long bonds, junk bonds, US small caps, commodities, and foreign stocks. Bet, (if you must), on US large caps, emerging markets, the dollar. Look to buy cheapening US real estate (buildings, NOT securities like REIT’s, which tend to lag) as the market continues to deteriorate. And remember to smile, as money’s not everything, after all.
Forecast Warning: In the end, financial forecasts are somewhat less reliable than long-range weather forecasts, and pundits tend (though not me, dear reader,) to trumpet their successful (lucky?) calls, and downplay (or conveniently forget) their bad ones. Take all you read here, and elsewhere, with a shaker of salt, and make sure to do your research and spread your risk. Most importantly, if your assets are not unlimited, and you truly care about your long term financial security (and who doesn’t when I put it that way?) use some sort of risk control program (like Camarda Financial’s ISIS® – more at camarda.com if you do not know of it) to balance exposure and hopefully increase the probability of good returns, while at the same time substantially lessening the risk of devastating losses – such as those encountered in the Great Crash of 2000-2003 – from which some investors will simply never recover. Good hunting, and good luck!